Rated 3.9 out of 5Â by 17
Rated 5 out of 5Â by haggis the best mascara, I have ever had, thank you.
This has too be the ever mascara, I had small eyes until I used this wonderful Product, and now I have eyes too envy
Rated 4 out of 5Â by D889 Good Mascara
It's great if you know how to use it, i.e. alternating with a defining brush to give volume and lift. Great richness and depth of colour.
Rated 1 out of 5Â by Sheryl Clumpiest Mascara Ever!
In the past I have used many high end mascaras, such as Chanel and Elizabeth Arden, and I thought I'd try the YSL Shocking Mascara. As soon as applied even just one coat, it turned my many thin eyelashes into about 5 clumps! Really poor quality and I tried to use it a few times since then and it has just clumped every time- for another 50p you can buy the Chanel one which is 1000x better.
Rated 1 out of 5Â by Laura28 Worst Mascara Ever
I wanted a mascara that wasn't completely black and a store assistant suggested this one as it is a blueish/grey shade. I have never paid this much for a mascara but decided to try it.
When I first applied it I was shocked at the result; far too much mascara was left on my lashes in big clumps. I had to use a clean mascara brush to clear off the clumps and then it actually looked good. I had to go through this procedure every time I applied it and it was obvious that this mascara would soon run out because of all the wastage.
The brush became absolutely clogged with mascara and I had to wash it in hot, soapy water to clear it. However, after the next use it became clogged again.
I was right about it not lasting long. I've not had it that long and it now needs throwing away.
A complete waste of money.
Rated 3 out of 5Â by Boogyanne Disappointing
I am going to be completely honest here. I am not sure whether it is the mascara at fault or whether Debenhams have some old stock. The last 4 mascaras that I have purchased online, of varying brands including Dior and Chanel, have been clumpy, messy and impossible to use effectively. I like maximum impact lashes with oodles of volume and length but I have begun to lose faith will all of them. YSL are normally a safe bet as far as mascaras go but if it wasn't for the wand from an old chanel mascara, I wouldn't have been able to get any use out of this product.
Rated 5 out of 5Â by Sok82 Love this product!
Love the length, volume and definition this mascara provides!! A must in my makeup bag!
Rated 5 out of 5Â by FLUFFYBUNNIE77 BEST MASCARA YET!
I originally tried YSL False Lash Effect Mascara about 5/6yrs ago and thought WOW I will never find any other Mascara to beat this.
But YSL have done it again, this SHOCKING Mascara really is fabulous, it just glides on, you really can feel the richness - it makes you feel a million dollars.
Believe me, if it can give me that 'Wide Eyed' look, it will work on anyone.
Just loving it.
Rated 3 out of 5Â by angelamy99 Good, but not the best
I was excited to try this mascara after hearing many positive review about it, and when I finally tried it I wasn't disappointed! It gave my lashes the dramatic thick volume I had been looking for in a mascara, two and a half weeks later I am still using this mascara on a daily basis but it is showing signs of drying up already, it still gives me the long lashes but you can tell the formula is not as wet as it was when I first had it, I was hoping it would be a month before any drying out would happen so this eliminates two stars. It is good but think there are better ones for lasting power than this one.