Rated 2.4 out of 5Â by 8
Rated 1 out of 5Â by beautyaddictgirl77 Disappointing
For something you can buy at an 1/8 of the price, I would have expected better, and definitely better from MAC.
Consistency was very watery, difficult to put on the eyelid, went on less than pure opaque black...which is really a bug bear of mine.. I like black make up products to be proper black (not see through black..slightly black... BLACK. It's a lot of money for a very small ink pot. AND after a few hours wear it's all over the place - smudging, flaking off, in your eyes.. not great, is it? There's far more cheaper better drugstores products than this.
Rated 1 out of 5Â by rachbee Worst liquid eyeliner I've ever used
I love liquid eyeliner and MAC's products so decided to give this one a go. Disgusted that I spent so much on this to be frank. Goes on like a cheap eyeliner and looks cheap when it's dried in. To get eyeliner on one eyelid you have to redip the applicator about ten times (if not more) and it takes forever to dry.
Would definitely not buy this again and still can't believe I wasted my money on such a disappointment.
Rated 1 out of 5Â by NickyJ For a Mac product this was really bad
I've used liquid eyeliner (black) for about 25 odd years, using both cheap and expensive makes over the years. I love Mac makeup so decided to try this ... big mistake, by the time I had finished my makeup I had lines above my lids. It had transferred. After an hour I had powdery residue underneath my eyes. Luckily I tried this in the house before actually wearing out. I looked like a panda as I went up to bed. Bad bad bad.
Rated 1 out of 5Â by Maisy Overpriced
I love Mac but so disappointed in this eye liner. It is hard to apply and dries funny. I am disappointed as I've wasted money. I thought I would try as it is waterproof. Won't be buying again!
Rated 1 out of 5Â by Pheonix Not Worth The Money
I purchased this eyeliner to replace a drugstore brand that I used on a daily basis. I expected good things as I have liked a lot of MAC products, but I was extremely disappointed! The applicator is great, but the liquid itself dries to a powder finish that falls out very easily, leaving black bits underneath the eyes. Would not recommend and will definitely not be buying again.
Rated 4 out of 5Â by LilyBettie Lovely, shame about the applicator
I do love this product, but i'm not so keen of the felt tip type of applicator. I find it harder to be as precise as I would be with any other applicator. I'll still be using it as it is a good product and I have got the hang of it, but I don't think I'll be rebuying. I would recommend to anyone who likes this type of thick applicator! I just prefer smaller ones.
Rated 5 out of 5Â by mac lover! New favourite
I absolutely love this eyeliner! I had been trying to find a good eyeliner for ages - this one provides a matt finish, which is a more subtle look than a really heavily glossy one, and you can really build a thick, dramatic line. It's also easy to draw a smaller line, and what I love is that it seems so much easier to get it right first time with this liner! It has now become my staple item in my make up bag - I've found my long lost eyeliner!
Rated 5 out of 5Â by mitch make up