Rated 2.9 out of 5Â by 30
Rated 1 out of 5Â by Annie May Very disappointing
Have used the mascara and it's great - this product is terrible - smudges, comes out in 'clumps' when you twist up smears over eyelid and didn't even last a couple of hours ! DO NOT BUY !!!
Rated 4 out of 5Â by Beki I was skeptical at first but I seriously love this
After reading other reviews I wasn't sure about buying this. Its not often I wear eyeliner so probably don't have loads of skill to start off with. But after wearing a fairly expensive (for Loreal) eyeliner that within an hour had completely come off I decided to give it a go. The lady in the shop put some on me. It takes a little bit of extra time to apply but is worth it. It didn't budge at all, even when wet. To take off I used they're real remover.
Rated 1 out of 5Â by KatieClarie So disappointing
I bought this eyeliner with high hopes. The first time I used it I absolutely loved it but every other time since its been a nightmare. It takes me twice as long to apply as any other eyeliner because it doesn't come out black and I have to apply over it, that is when it comes out at all. It's crumbly and I end up with black flecks under my eye that smudge horrifically when I try to get rid of them. It doesn't stay put for long at all and I find that within a few hours my wings have completely gone. Really disappointed by this product as I've heard such good things from benefit as a brand.
Rated 5 out of 5Â by Kingg12 Great if given a chance!
When i first used this eyeliner i thought (similar to most peoples views) 'Oh god this is terrible' I thought it was difficult to apply and messy so i put it away and that was that. Recently I've dug it back up and i love it, yes it takes a bit of getting used to but its actually pretty easy to apply. It is intensely black and this intensity stays all day, opposed to cheaper liners which tend to fade. I would definitely recommend this product if you are patient enough to get to grips with it!
Rated 1 out of 5Â by Pandapops Disappointing
I bought this as a recommendation before going away on holiday as it claims to be smudge and waterproof.
I wear my liner quite thick on top (with wing) and line the bottom on my eyes and I found the liner on the top stayed quite well throughout the day but the bottom had all smudged off by the end of a day in the sun, so definitely not smudge proof.
Application is also extremely fiddly and messy. The style of the nib doesn't work well the texture of the liner at all. You'll find sometimes you'll turn the bottom bit and too much will come out and when you try to apply it'll just break and crumb off as you apply leaving wasted bits of product everywhere. If you turn the bottom bit less; not enough will come out and you'll end up having to pinch the nib to squidge a little product out.
Product itself is only pigmented when you re apply several times. Otherwise will come out flakey, and light if only applied once.
I've actually gone back to using my Maybelline gel liner as an alternative as it's easier to apply, more pigmented and staying power is about the same as this one, and was much cheaper! Still on the search for a good smudge/waterproof liner!
Rated 1 out of 5Â by unknow90008 Worst Eye Liner I have ever owned
I thought I'd try this product, but what a mistake. It is by far the worst eye liner I have ever brought. The eyeliner is very hard to apply, and even if you can apply it you end up having lumps of black all over eyes and lashes. I have wasted more because of wiping the top of the product. Massive mistake moving away from Urban Decay....
Rated 1 out of 5Â by supersue rubbish im afraid
was recommended this as an alternative to macs gel liners at benefit counter - I use eyeliner everyday but the product was dried in the tip everday I went to use it - when I eventually got it to work too much was left on my lids and it irritated my eyes - waste of money - test your products properly benefit
Rated 4 out of 5Â by Lisa_Woody Good Eyeliner but messy
I thought I would try this eyeliner and I must admit it is one of the best I have tried as they all seem to crease on my eye lids. The only problem it is messy and some of the product gets wasted. but on the whole I would recommend and I'm going to buy again.