Rated 2.8 out of 5Â by 36
Rated 1 out of 5Â by Beckie Poor Product
I bought this eyeliner as I've recently tried other Benefit products and been really happy with them. The eyeliner itself once applied doesn't smudge and stays on for as long as desired however applying the eyeliner is horrendous. The liquid clogs up in the tip becoming lumpy. I was advised to leave a plastic (T shaped) devise in the top after use however has little affect. Cleaning the tip results in eyeliner all over and numerous lines on the back of your hand until its running smooth. I wouldn't buy again.
Rated 1 out of 5Â by Claire Dreadful product
When I considered buying this I was provided with the demo. It dispensed lumps of eyeliner rather than any sort of gel. I was told not to worry, the demo had been out a long time, the actual product was great. Well the actual product was just as bad with lumps of eyeliner caking along the eye between the gel. I took it back to the shop and was told I needed to squeeze the tip with my fingers before applying; not the best design considering that make up remover is then required to clean your hands. Not the best advice either since it made no difference to the gel consistency; it was basically a product without a use.
Rated 1 out of 5Â by Queen4aday Worst eye liner I have ever had
I bought this eyeliner because they do a green shade which is hard to find as a rule. I asked the salesgirl if it contained fibres (I wear contact lens) and she said it did not. When I tried it the next day it was fiddly and not very smooth - a bit smudgey. It also irratated my eyes. I tried to persevere with it but in the end binned it, and God help you if the flakes fall off because they stain like paint. Worst eye product I have ever bought - shall never buy Benefit again. Only one star for the colour which is a really good dark green.
Rated 1 out of 5Â by Mas222267 Worst eyeliner I've ever bought
The applicator just smeared it all over my eyelids, it was clumpy and dry and I found that it leaked out and dried all over the lid, complete waste of money.
Rated 5 out of 5Â by harls72 it's just beautiful
It doesn't budge, it's really simple to use and it looks beautiful. Really worth the price and it lasts a really long time. I wear eyeliner everyday and it lasted me about 6 months.
Rated 5 out of 5Â by Doris It's the best
Purchased as a gift for my niece, It's the only make she wears & swears by it.
Rated 1 out of 5Â by Annie May Very disappointing
Have used the mascara and it's great - this product is terrible - smudges, comes out in 'clumps' when you twist up smears over eyelid and didn't even last a couple of hours ! DO NOT BUY !!!
Rated 4 out of 5Â by Beki I was skeptical at first but I seriously love this
After reading other reviews I wasn't sure about buying this. Its not often I wear eyeliner so probably don't have loads of skill to start off with. But after wearing a fairly expensive (for Loreal) eyeliner that within an hour had completely come off I decided to give it a go. The lady in the shop put some on me. It takes a little bit of extra time to apply but is worth it. It didn't budge at all, even when wet. To take off I used they're real remover.